Skip to content
Health Work NYHealthcare Careers & Workforce / Consumer Health
HWN
Health Work NYHealthcare Careers & Workforce / Consumer Health
Workplace

Workplace bullying and health: what the research documents

Prospective studies tie workplace bullying to new depression and more certified sick leave. What the symptom surveys and the Finnish hospital cohorts found.

Workplace bullying and health: what the research documents
GwenFord / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Workplace bullying leaves measurable marks on health: the strongest forward-looking data tie it to depression and to time away from work. In a 2003 study of 5,432 hospital staff in Occupational and Environmental Medicine, prolonged bullying carried an odds ratio of 4.2 for new depression over two years.

The research defines the term narrowly. Gary and Ruth Namie, two researchers in this field, describe bullying as repeated, -harming mistreatment that can include verbal abuse or sabotage, a definition carried in the Wikipedia entry on workplace bullying. Repetition sets bullying apart from a single conflict. The same entry cites the 2015 National Health Interview Survey: 7.4 percent of workers reported being bullied or harassed on the job.

What counts as workplace bullying?

The definition matters because the health studies measure repeated exposure, not one hard week. The field treats bullying at work as sustained mistreatment that harms health and blocks work. Rates vary by industry. The 2015 survey data put health and social assistance at the top, with 10 percent of its workers reporting a hostile work setting, the top rate of any broad group. We covered a connected angle in New York's ICU nurse-staffing rule is four years old. Hospitals still miss it more than half the time, union data show.

How does the stress show up in the body?

Researchers at Arizona State University, quoted in the Wikipedia entry, call stress the main health effect tied to bullying. The clearest symptom tables come from an interested party: the Workplace Bullying Institute, an advocacy group, surveyed 516 self-identified targets in 2012. Their reports centered on stress:

  • disruption and insomnia, at the top of a 77 to 50 percent range
  • panic attacks, at 52 percent
  • migraine headaches, at 48 percent
  • irritable bowel disorder, at 37 percent
  • chronic fatigue syndrome, at 33 percent

Nearly half of the group, 49 percent, reported a diagnosis of clinical depression. The numbers are self-reported, and the institute sells training, so the set reads best as one signal among several.

What do the long-term studies find?

The strongest designs follow workers over time. The 2003 cohort study reported an odds ratio of 4.2 for new depression among victims of prolonged bullying, and the link held after adjustment for sex, age and income. The same study put the odds ratio for new cardiovascular disease at 2.3. The authors noted that this signal weakened to 1.6 after adjustment for overweight, and they read that as a partial cause.

A 2000 study in the same journal tracked sick leave among 5,655 hospital staff. Workers who reported bullying had 1.5 times more certified sick leave than the rest. The gap held after adjustment for demographics and prior health. Both papers come from the same Finnish research group, a fact worth knowing when one figure gets quoted.

What about post-traumatic stress?

Studies summed up in the Wikipedia entry put post-traumatic stress disorder among the known outcomes. Tehrani found one in ten targets had PTSD, and Matthiesen and Einarsen reported the condition in up to 77 percent of targets. The spread shows how much measurement choices matter. Any single figure deserves a slow read.

When should someone talk to a clinician?

The survey data give a practical marker: most targets already seek help. In the 2012 Workplace Bullying Institute survey, 71 percent of those surveyed saw a doctor for work-related symptoms, and 63 percent saw a mental health professional. Persistent sleep loss is a known reason to book that visit. The same holds for panic symptoms or a low mood that does not lift once the pressure ends. A clinician can also document the link between symptoms and work, which matters in any complaint.

Conclusion: The bottom line

The pattern in the studies is steady. Bullying at work tracks with disturbed sleep and new depression, and it raises certified sick leave in cohort studies. Rates sit near 7 percent nationally and run higher in health care. The practical step is an early visit to a doctor, because most targets already sought one, and an early visit starts the record of the harm. Readers following this should also see Health care workers get hurt on the job at rates above almost every other industry.

Frequently Asked Questions

How common is workplace bullying in the United States?
The 2015 National Health Interview Survey found 7.4 percent of workers reported being threatened, bullied or harassed by anyone on the job, and health care and social assistance led all broad industry groups at 10 percent. The figure covers reported cases, and definitions vary between surveys.
What health problems are linked to workplace bullying?
Documented links include disturbed sleep and insomnia, panic attacks, migraine headaches, irritable bowel disorder and chronic fatigue syndrome, with clinical depression reported by 49 percent of surveyed targets. Prospective evidence adds new depression and 1.5 times more certified sickness absence among bullied hospital staff.
Is the cardiovascular risk from bullying settled?
No. The 2003 Finnish cohort found an odds ratio of 2.3 for new cardiovascular disease after prolonged bullying, but adjustment for overweight cut it to 1.6, a range compatible with no effect. The depression association was far stronger, at 4.2, and held after the same adjustments.

Sources

  1. Workplace bullying - Wikipedia — Wikipedia
  2. Workplace bullying and the risk of cardiovascular disease and depression (PubMed record) — PubMed, National Library of Medicine
  3. Workplace bullying and sickness absence in hospital staff (PubMed record) — PubMed, National Library of Medicine

More from our brands

Part of the VUGA Network
VUGA NetworkOUR BRANDS